
EDIT:
Had this all typed up before I realized Paul had his take on Superman Returns posted up, so please, read his post first if you haven't yet because he makes a few good points on the film.In THIS corner, weighing in at roughly 155 pounds and standing at a height of 5 feet 10 inches, without doubt the worst pirate you've ever heard of--but you HAVE heard of him--the incredible, the magnificent, the strangely arousing CAPTAIN Jack Sparrow!
And in THIS corner, weighing in at approximately 218 pounds and standing at an impressive 6 foot 3 inches, the Man of Steel himself! Faster than a speeding bullet, more powerful than a locomotive, capable of becoming the biggest dork with a single pair of glasses, it's SUPERMAN!
So, whether you're rooting for the pirate or the superhero, I'd say we're in for a good fight. Let's get it on!
First up:
Pirates of the Caribbean: Dead Man's Chest. After Depp's wonderful performance in the first Pirates film, Dead Man's Chest was a welcome release just to enjoy the antics of Jack Sparrow alone. He's sly, he's cunning, he's surprising--he's a pirate. And if you don't like that, the girls can drool over Mr. Orlando Bloom--oh-so-dashing and debonair--and the lovely Kiera Knightly, whose accent makes her twice as hawt as she already is.
But enough of the fantasies, let's get down to business--spoiler free. Dead Man's Chest is a great film. Everything you loved about The Curse of the Black Pearl is here in this movie, not to mention the generous nods to the classic Disney attraction--more on that later--but let me first point out some of the faults Pirate's run aground on.
First, the story. Our more intelligent individuals will be able to keep up with the fast-paced plot well enough, but just as the first film was a little tough to follow, the second is three times as difficult to keep up with. Then there's the end of the film which isn't a bad ending at all--it just leaves some loose ends untied because, quite naturally, it's a set up for the third film, At World's End, which will be out next year just in time to compete with Spider-Man 3, naturally. There's certainly many things to be speculated upon, including the intriguing love triangle between Will, Elizabeth and Jack. And also the appearance of a character without clear explanation--it makes for a good film, but I'll still be scratching my head until this time next year.
I don't think Dead Man's Chest is as good as The Curse of the Black Pearl. I think that the first movie will forever be the best, but that doesn't mean Dead Man's Chest isn't worth your money and time. This is definitely a must see.
Props go to Johnny, who is as entertaining as always, and whomever was responsible for the CG work on Davy Jones because it's not often you can make a CG character display good emotion. And the Kraken is a nice touch--another nod to the theme parks, but not necessarily the rides, again, more on that later.
Oh yes, and the wonderful Abbot and Costello/Laurel and Hardy stylings of Lee Arenberg (Pintel) and Mackenzie Crook (Ragetti) who could probably have their own animated Saturday Morning Cartoon show on ABC if Disney were greedy enough--that would totally ruin that kudo--I hope they don't do that, now. I've jinxed 'em.
And a nod also to Gore Verbinski and his crew for some of the most incredible shots I've seen in movie-making, particularly the fight scene on the runaway waterwheel. When you see the shot, you'll know what I'm talking about. Anyways, thank you, Bruckheimer, for making the only attraction-based Disney film that DIDN'T suck... damn Eddie Murphy and damn Rob Minkoff...
But WAIT! Pirates isn't the only big time blockbuster out this summer, no! Look! Up in the sky! It's a bird! It's a plane! It's... well, you get the picture.
There's something you need to know before we get any further:
Superman Returns is basically Superman 5. It picks up after the end of
Superman IV: The Quest for Peace, so brushing up on your 1980's Superman knowledge is advisable but not necessary to enjoy the film. Basically, Superman has been gone to what he believed were the remains of Krypton for many years and finally shows up only to find Lex Luthor up to his old tricks.
Okay, here's my biggest nitpick of the whole movie--and it's not that it's so incredibly long--Pirates had a pretty good-size length to it also. Superman Returns is simple. No complicated plot twists, no super surprises--well, perhaps one or two--really, the whole film follows the standard superhero formula.
And that's not necessarily a bad thing. I can't imagine Superman Returns is going to be the kind of incredible re-imagining that Batman Begins was--that's expecting FAR too much of ANY movie--but in its design and its execution, Superman Returns is, at its root, a GOOD movie, despite the simplicity of the situation, it's a GOOD movie. Not the greatest or the best, but good.
Again, the length will be challenging to those with small bladders and even smaller attention spans, but to see Brandon Routh as Superman flying, using his powers and generally saving the day, there's a good feeling there. Accompanied by the classic Superman score, the overall result really gets your blood pumping.
I love superhero movies, so Superman Returns was fun to watch, but I would've loved to see Superman get challenged more often to save the day.
So props go to Bryan Singer for doing the Superman franchise justice and not screwing it up--plus to James Marsden (a.k.a. Cyclops) who played a likable character as his role. Oh yeah, and Kevin Spacey for his Luthor--while I prefer the no-nonsense style of Lex from the animated series, Spacey did a fine job.
So, at the end of the battle, who will come out on top? While the real Jack Sparrow probably couldn't hold a candle to Superman, it seems that Disney's Pirates might just make off with the title of best summer film this year...
... and no, Snakes on a Plane doesn't come out August 18, so don't bug me about that one yet...